Author Topic: 2012 March Madness Nominations (Read 4008 times)

Chronic Apathy · « **on:** February 05, 2012, 12:23:10 AM »

This is (hopefully soon-to-be-official) March Madness nominations thread. The point is to use a bracket system and put different heroes head-to-head for people to vote on who they think is better. Every 2 days, voting closes and we move up the bracket until we have a winner. The nominations will at least start the same way they did last year; nominate your favorite heroes from each brigade (up to eight of each brigade), ranking them in order of who you think is the best. The best eight from each brigade (including a "multi" brigade) will compete in Redemption March Madness. The reigning leader, Susanna, remains strong; can she hold the crown?

Warrior_Monk · « **Reply #1 on:** February 05, 2012, 12:26:55 AM »

Purple
King Amazing
Matthew
John (G)
Abigail
Thomas
Philip
King David
Thaddeus

Silver
Angel Under the Oak
TSA (Warriors)
Captain (Kings)
Cherubim (FooF/RoA)
Gabriel (Di)
Angel of Warning
Angel with a Secret Name (FooF/RoA)
Angel at Shur (Promo)

Green
Isaiah
Micah
Hosea
Hur
Benaiah
Daniel
Armorbearer
Ezekiel

Teal
Aaron
Abiathar
Phineas
Joiada
Joshua
Ahimaaz
Melk
Elishama

Gold
Moses
Samuel
The Generous Widow
Watchful Servant
Simeon (wa)
Gideon
Jair
Woman at the Well

Blue
Joseph
Jacob
Rachel
Zebulun
Benjamin
Asher
Ira
Claudia

Red
Ishmaiah
Asahel
Ahimilek
Centurion at Calvary
Heldai
Jepthah
Jael
Spy

White
Susanna
Mary, Mother of James
Chenaniah
Lydia
Salome
Joanna
King Amazing
Mary Mag

Minister Polarius · « **Reply #2 on:** February 05, 2012, 01:28:26 AM »

Purple:
King Amaziah

Silver:
The Angel under the Oak

Green:
Hur

Teal:
Phinehas

Gold:
Moses

Blue:
Zebulun

Red:
Asahel

White:
MMoJ

Multi:
Samuel
Joseph

Red Wing · « **Reply #3 on:** February 05, 2012, 09:40:52 AM »

Purple
King Amazing
E.T.
John (Starter)
Abigail
King Hiram
Matthew
King David
Thaddeus

Silver
Angel Under the Oak
TSA (Warriors)
Captain (Kings)
Cherubim (New)
Gabriel (Di)
Angel of Warning
Angel with a Secret Name (New)
Angel at Shur (Promo)

Green
Isaiah
Micah
Hosea
Hur
Simeon (Di)
Anna (Di)
John the Baptist (Di)
Armorbearer

Teal
Phineas
Priests of Christ
Abiathar
Joiada
Joshua
Ahimaaz
Melk

Gold
Moses
The Generous Widow
Watchful Servant
Simeon (Wa)
Gideon
Jair (New)
Samson
Woman at the Well

Blue
Jacob
Rachel
Zebulun
Eve
Benjamin
Asher
Ira
Claudia

Red
Ishmaiah
Asahel
Ahimilek
Centurion at Calvary
Uriah (New)
Jepthah
David (W/C)
Spy

White
Susanna
Mary, Mother of James
Lydia
Chenaniah
Salome
Joanna
King Amazing
Mary Mag

Multi
Samuel
Joseph
Daniel
Aaron (Di)
Ezekiel
Faithful Servant
Simon the Zealot
Melk (RoA)

The M · « **Reply #4 on:** February 05, 2012, 09:43:57 AM »

IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER:

Purple
King Amazing
Matthew
Abigail
Philip
King David

Silver
Angel Under the Oak
TSA (Warriors)
Captain (Kings)
Cherubim (FooF/RoA)
Angel with a Secret Name (FooF/RoA)

Green
Isaiah
Micah
Hosea
Benaiah
Armorbearer

Teal

Abiathar
Phineas
Joiada
Joshua
Elishama

Gold
Moses
The Generous Widow
Watchful Servant
Gideon
Jair
Woman at the Well

Blue
Jacob
Rachel
Zebulun
Benjamin
Ira

Red
Ishmaiah
Asahel
Ahimilek
Heldai
Jepthah

White
Susanna
Mary, Mother of James
Salome
Joanna
Mary Mag

Multi
Daniel
Aaron
Joseph
Samuel
FSP

Red · « **Reply #5 on:** February 05, 2012, 10:02:13 AM »

updating as I compile the lists.
Silver
Angel Under the Oak
TSA (Warriors)
Captain (Kings)
Cherubim (FooF/RoA)
Gabriel (Di)
Angel of Warning
Angel with a Secret Name (FooF/RoA)
Angel at Shur (Promo)

Gold
Moses
Watchful servant
Gideon
Jair
The woman at the well
Ehud
The generous widow
Samson

blue
Zebulun
Ira(kings)
Rachel
Eve
simeon
Benjamin
Asher
claudia

Red
Ahimlek the hittite
David
The two centourians
Ismahiah
Uriah the hittite
Ashahel
Jepthath

Green
Micah
Isaiah
Hosea
Simeon Di
anna Di
Armorbearer
John the baptist
Benahiah(kings)

Teal:

Jaddua(I don't play teal so I'll pick him)
Abiathar
Phineas
Joiada
Joshua
Ahimaaz
Melk
Elishama

Purple:
Thaddeus
King amaziah
Abagail
Matthew
Philip
Bartholmew
ET
john(Gdeck)

white:
susanna
King amaziah
Salome
Mary mother of james
Joanna
Mary mag
lydia
Mahrai

Nameless · « **Reply #6 on:** February 06, 2012, 06:39:58 PM »

Purple
King Amazing
Matthew
John (G)
Abigail
Thomas
Philip
King David
Thaddeus

Silver
Angel Under the Oak
TSA (Warriors)
Captain (Kings)
Cherubim (FooF/RoA)
Seraph with the Live Coal
Angel with a Secret Name (FooF/RoA)
Angel at Shur (Promo)

Green
Isaiah
Micah
Hosea
Hur
Daniel

Teal
Aaron
Abiathar
Phineas
Joshua
Ahimaaz
Melk

Gold
Moses
Samuel
The Generous Widow
Watchful Servant
Sampson
Gideon
Jair
Woman at the Well

Blue
Joseph
Jacob
Rachel
Zebulun
Benjamin
Asher
Eve

Red
Ishmaiah
Asahel
Ahimilek
Centurion at Calvary
Heldai
Jepthah
Uriah
Spy

White
Susanna
Mary Mother of James
Chenaniah
Lydia
Salome
Joanna
King Amazing
Mary Mag

Professoralstad · « **Reply #7 on:** February 06, 2012, 11:48:44 PM »

So, if you include multi Heroes as a separate brigade, then you'll have 72 Heroes in the bracket...how are you going to manage that? I would suggest doing top 7 from each brigade, then having one wildcard hero (or maybe two heroes could have a play-in match before the actual tournament). Whichever two heroes get the most votes out of the heroes who don't make the top 7 of their respective brigades.

Otherwise, you could keep it like last year and have multi characters be any of the brigades they have.

Anyway, my nominations:

Blue:

1. Jacob
2. Rachel
3. Zebulun
4. Eve
5. Benjamin
6. Ira (Kings)
7. Simeon
8. Asher

Gold:

1. Watchful Servant
2. Moses
3. The Woman at the Well
4. The Generous Widow
5. Gideon
6. Ehud
7. Jair
8. Lazarus

Green:

1. Isaiah
2. Simeon
3. Armorbearer
4. Hur
5. Anna
6. Benaiah
7. Micah
8. Nathan

Multi:

1. Joseph
2. Samuel
3. Daniel
4. Faithful Servant
5. Simon the Zealot
6. Ezekiel
7. Aaron
8. Jeremiah

Purple:

1. Thaddeus
2. King Amaziah
3. Matthew
4. King David
5. Abigail
6. Ethiopian Treasurer
7. John (G)
8. Philip

Red:

1. Ahimelek, the Hittite
2. Ishmaiah, the Gibeonite
3. Asahel
4. Heldai
5. The Centurion at Calvary
6. Spy
7. The Centurion at Capernaum
8. Abishai

Silver:

1. The Angel Under the Oak
2. The Strong Angel
3. Cherubim
4. Captain of the Host
5. Angel with the Secret Name
6. Michael (Kings)
7. Gabriel (Wa)
8. Seraph with the Live Coal

Teal:

1. Phinehas, Son of Eleazar
2. Abiathar
3. Joiada, Son of Eliashib
4. Joshua the High Priest
5. Priests of Christ
6. Ahimaaz
7. Seraiah the High Priest
8. Jaddua, son of Jonathan

White

1. Susanna
2. Mary, Mother of James
3. Salome
4. Chenaiah
5. Maharai (Kings)
6. Lydia
7. Mary Magdalene
8. Joanna

Chronic Apathy · « **Reply #8 on:** February 07, 2012, 12:22:55 AM »

Quote from: Professoralstad on February 06, 2012, 11:48:44 PM

So, if you include multi Heroes as a separate brigade, then you'll have 72 Heroes in the bracket...how are you going to manage that? I would suggest doing top 7 from each brigade, then having one wildcard hero (or maybe two heroes could have a play-in match before the actual tournament). Whichever two heroes get the most votes out of the heroes who don't make the top 7 of their respective brigades.

Otherwise, you could keep it like last year and have multi characters be any of the brigades they have.

Bryon is taking over after the nomination process; I'm just making sure the nominations run smoothly and answer any questions that might arise. He is welcome to do multi however he wishes, since it's his pet, not mine.

soul seeker · « **Reply #9 on:** February 07, 2012, 10:53:42 AM »

I nominate:

Purple:
Jonathan Greeson

Green:
Jonathan Greeson

White:
John Earley

These cards were sooooo awesome that Rob Anderson banned them. Yes, the only banned cards* in the game...they must be broken!!!11!!one!!!

* Sorry if you have a 2010 promo card, and I couldn't remember it's color or your full name, but I would nominate you as well.

TheHobbit13 · « **Reply #10 on:** February 07, 2012, 11:11:03 AM »

Here are mine
Blue:

1. Jacob
2. Rachel
3. Zebulun
4. Eve
5. Benjamin
6. Ira (Kings)
7. Simeon
8. Asher

Gold:

1. Watchful Servant
2. Moses
3. The Woman at the Well
4. The Generous Widow
5. Gideon
6. Ehud
7. Jair
8. Samson (limited)

Green:

1. Isaiah
2. Simeon
3. Armorbearer
4. Hur
5. Anna
6. Benaiah (Kings)
7. Micah
8. Habakkuk

Multi:

1. Samuel
2. Joseph
3. Daniel
4. Ezekiel
5. Aaron
6. Faithful Servant
7. Simon the Zealot
8. Seeker of the Lost

Purple:

1. Thaddeus
2. Philip
3. Matthew
4. King Amaziah
5. King David
6. Ethiopian Treasurer
7. John (G)
8. King Solomon

Red:

1. Ishmaiah, the Gibeonite
2. Ahimelek, the Hittite
3. Asahel
4. Heldai
5. The Centurion at Calvary
6. Uriah the Hittite
7. The Centurion at Capernaum
8. Abishai

Silver:

1. The Angel Under the Oak
2. The Strong Angel
3. Seraph with the Live Coal
4. Captain of the Host
5. Angel with the Secret Name
6. Michael (Kings)
7. Gabriel (Wa)
8. Cheribum

Teal:

1. Phinehas, Son of Eleazar
2. Abiathar
3. Joiada, Son of Eliashib
4. Joshua the High Priest
5. Priests of Christ
6. Ahimaaz
7. Seraiah the High Priest
8. Jaddua, son of Jonathan

White

1. Susanna
2. Mary, Mother of James
3. Salome
4. Chenaiah
5. Maharai (Kings)
6. Lydia
7. Mary Magdalene
8. Joanna

Drrek · « **Reply #11 on:** February 07, 2012, 11:37:21 AM »

Blue:
1. Benjamin
2. Zebulun
3. Rachel
4. Jacob
5. Ira
6. Dan
7. Judah
8. Simeon

Gold:
1. Watchful Servant
2. Gideon
3. Jair
4. Moses
5. Lazarus
6. The Generous Widow
7. The Thankful Leper
8. The Woman at the Well

Red:
1. Ishmaiah
2. Asahel
3. Ahimelek
4. Centurion at Calvary
5. Centurion at Capernaum
6. Uriah
7. Spy
8. Abishai

Silver:
1. Angel Under the Oak
2. Cherubim
3. Angel with a secret Name
4. Captain of the Host
5. Seraph with the Live Coal
6. Michael
7. Gabriel (wa)
8. Strong Angel

Purple:
1. Matthew
2. Phillip
3. King Amaziah
4. John
5. King David
6. Abigail
7. Thomas
8. Thaddeus

Green:
1. Isaiah
2. Hosea
3. Simeon
4. John the Baptist
5. Armorbearer
6. Anna
7. Micah
8. Nathan

White:
1. Mary, Mother of James
2. Susanna
3. Salome
4. Mary Magdalene
5. Joanna
6. Lydia
7. Maharai
8. King Amaziah

Teal:
1. Phinehas
2. Joiada
3. Joshua
4. Ahimaaz
5. Priests of Christ
6. Abiathar
7. Jaddua
8. Elishama

Multi:
1. Samuel
2. Joseph
3. Daniel
4. Ezekiel
5. Aaron
6. Faithful Servant
7. Simon the Zealot
8. Melchizedek

Warrior_Monk · « **Reply #12 on:** February 07, 2012, 01:30:51 PM »

Wow. Have people forgotten how awesome Simeon (wa) is, or am I the crazy one?

Chronic Apathy · « **Reply #13 on:** February 07, 2012, 03:01:09 PM »

Timothy will win.

Silver:
The Angel Under the Oak
Captain of the Host
The Strong Angel
Cheribum
Seraph
Angel with the Secret Name
Seraph with a Live Coal
Gabriel

Red:
Ahimelek the Hittite
Asahel
Heldai
Ishmaiah the Gibeonite
Jephthah
Peter
The Centurion at Calvary
The Centurion at Capernaum

Blue:
Benjamin
Simeon
Zebulun
Eve
Rachel
Ira
Asher
Jacob

Green:
Isaiah
Beneniah
Micah
John the Baptist
Hur
Hosea
Armorbearer
Simeon

Purple:
Thaddeus
Matthew
Philip
Bartholomew
King David
King Amazing
King Solomon
Abigail

White:
Mary the Mother of James
Susanna
Joanna
Mary Magdalene
Lydia
Salome
Chenaniah
Timothy

Teal:
Phinehas, son of Eleazar
Joshua the High Priest
Priests of Christ
Abiathar
Ahimaaz
Joiada, Son of Eliashib
Melkchizedek

Gold:
Moses
Jair
Ehud
Woman at the Well
Gideon
Watchful Servant
The Generous Widow
Eli the Priest

Multi:
Samuel
Joseph
Aaron
Melchizedek
Ezekiel
Faithful Servant
Daniel
Simon the Zealot

Drrek · « **Reply #14 on:** February 07, 2012, 03:33:52 PM »

Quote from: Chronic Apathy on February 07, 2012, 03:01:09 PM

Gabriel

Which Gabriel are you referring to? The one from from Disciples has a vastly different ability from the ones from Warriors and Kings.

Also if we need to get rid of the multi category, maybe we should have people place them in the brigade where they think they most belong. That's my suggestion on how we should do it anyay.

Chronic Apathy · « **Reply #15 on:** February 07, 2012, 03:44:58 PM »

I don't think it really matters which Gabriel; he's not going to make it far enough to really matter (he might win his first round, maybe the second, definitely not the third), so I'm not too concerned about it. Regarding multi-heroes, I like Prof A's suggestion that we'll take the top seven of any brigades affected by it, probably by what brigade a character is most used as (Zeke would be Green, Sam would be Gold, Joseph would be Blue, etc).

Prof Underwood · « **Reply #16 on:** February 07, 2012, 03:57:03 PM »

I think Seven Sons of Sceva should fall in the Orange Brigade of ECs (when we get to that), and there could be some heroes that would also work like that.

Alex_Olijar · « **Reply #17 on:** February 07, 2012, 04:11:39 PM »

I disagree. I think I should be able to vote for Joseph in both brigades and if he gets enough votes he can be in both brigades.

Drrek · « **Reply #18 on:** February 07, 2012, 04:15:13 PM »

Quote from: Alex_Olijar on February 07, 2012, 04:11:39 PM

I disagree. I think I should be able to vote for Joseph in both brigades and if he gets enough votes he can be in both brigades.

So you want Samuel to win both Gold and Green? Because I think that is exactly what would happen they were allowed to be in both brigades, and while I don't necessarily think that would be a bad thing, personally I'd like to see a different card represent each brigade.

Prof Underwood · « **Reply #19 on:** February 07, 2012, 04:37:31 PM »

Quote from: Drrek on February 07, 2012, 04:15:13 PM

So you want Samuel to win both Gold and Green? Because I think that is exactly what would happen they were allowed to be in both brigades, and while I don't necessarily think that would be a bad thing, personally I'd like to see a different card represent each brigade.

Besides no one would vote for SSoS as a crimson EC. But considering that he has CBN ability to turn into any other Orange brigade demon and takes out the artifact that would completely destroy an Orange defense (and can be pulled out of your deck by Unknown Nation), he might have a chance in voting on Orange.

Warrior_Monk · « **Reply #20 on:** February 07, 2012, 05:56:46 PM »

Quote from: Prof Underwood on February 07, 2012, 04:37:31 PM

Quote from: Drrek on February 07, 2012, 04:15:13 PM
So you want Samuel to win both Gold and Green? Because I think that is exactly what would happen they were allowed to be in both brigades, and while I don't necessarily think that would be a bad thing, personally I'd like to see a different card represent each brigade.
Besides no one would vote for SSoS as a crimson EC. But considering that he has CBN ability to turn into any other Orange brigade demon and takes out the artifact that would completely destroy an Orange defense (and can be pulled out of your deck by Unknown Nation), he might have a chance in voting on Orange.

Disagree. This is only a problem for somebody who uses your voting system. Just because a card is a different brigade than it's theme doesn't make it worthless. SSS is still a great card to assist orange brigade, but it is still categorized by it's brigade (which is a much better way of categorizing things than themes).

Does it really matter what brigade Uzzah is? No. He's optimized by being able to use Plot, but if we remove the category barrior, he'll be in every single category because he fits with every single defense.

Minister Polarius · « **Reply #21 on:** February 07, 2012, 07:09:38 PM »

SSoS has no chance against Nebuchadnezzar or KoT in either case.

MitchRobStew · « **Reply #22 on:** February 07, 2012, 07:45:17 PM »

Silver:
1. The Angel Under the Oak
2. Captain of the Host (Ki)
3. The Strong Angel
4. Cherubim
5. Seraph with a Live Coal
6. Michael (Ki)
7. Attending Angel
8. Gabriel (Di)

Blue:
1. Jacob
2. Rachel
3. Benjamin
4. Zebulun
5. Eve
6. Ira
7. Asher
8. Simeon

Green:
1. Isaiah
2. Simeon
3. Armorbearer
4. Hur
5. Anna
6. Benaiah
7. Micah
8. Hosea

Red:
1. Ahimelek the Hittite
2. Ishmaiah the Gibeonite
3. Asahel
4. Heldai
5. Jephthah
6. The Centurion at Calvary
7. The Centurion at Capernaum
8. Peter

Purple:
1. Thaddeus
2. Matthew
3. Philip
5. King Amaziah
6. Abigail
7. King Solomon
8. Ethiopian Treasurer

White:
1. Susanna
2. Mary, Mother of James
3. Salome
4. Joanna
5. Lydia
6. Mary Magdalene
7. Chenaniah
8. Maharai (Ki)

Gold:
1. The Woman at the Well
2. Moses
3. Watchful Servant
4. The Generous Widow
5. Gideon
6. Jair
7. Samson (Limited)
8. Ehud

Multi:
1. Samuel
2. Joseph
3. Daniel
4. Ezekiel
5. Aaron
6. Faithful Servant
7. Melchizedek
8. Simon the Zealot

Wings of Music · « **Reply #23 on:** February 27, 2012, 04:00:57 PM »

Silver:
1. The Strong Angel
2. AutO
3. Captain
4. Cherubim
5. Seraph with a Live Coal
6. Michael (Ki)
7. AwSN
8. Gabriel (Di)

Blue:
1. Zeb
2. Ben
3. Jacob
4. Rachel
5. Eve
6. Ira
7. Asher
8. Judah

Green:
1. Isaiah
2. Hur
3. Benaiah
4. Simeon
5. Anna
6. John The Baptist
7. Micah
8. Hosea

Red:
1. Ahimelek the Hittite
2. Asahel
3. Ishmaiah the Gibeonite
4. Jephthah
5. The Centurion at Calvary
6. The Centurion at Capernaum
7. Peter
8. Uriah the Hittite

Purple:
1. King Amazing
2. Matthew
3. Ethiopian Treasurer
5. Bartholomew
6. Philip
7. John (G/H)
8. Thaddeus

White:
1. Susanna
2. Mary, Mother of James
3. Salome
4. Joanna
5. Lydia
6. Mary Magdalene
7. King Amazing
8. Maharai

Gold:
1. Moses
2. Watchful Servant
3. The Woman at the Well
4. The Generous Widow
5. Jair
6. Ehud
7. Lazarus
8. Gideon

Multi:
1. Joseph
2. Daniel
3. Samuel
4. Aaron
5. Saul/Paul (As Paul)
6. Zeke
7. Simon the Zealot
8. Melchizedek

EDIT: forgot about John and Peter

CJSports · « **Reply #24 on:** February 27, 2012, 05:58:29 PM »

Orange:
Seven Wicked Spirits

Thank you Andrew for opening my eyes on the wonders of this card.

News:

Author Topic: 2012 March Madness Nominations (Read 4008 times)

Chronic Apathy

Warrior_Monk

Chronic Apathy

TheHobbit13

Warrior_Monk

Chronic Apathy

Chronic Apathy

Warrior_Monk