Cactus Game Design Message Boards
Redemption® Collectible Trading Card Game HQ => Official Rules & Errata => Ruling Questions => Topic started by: JDS on August 20, 2010, 11:56:29 AM
-
The High Priests' guards are considered sadducees, are their servants?
-
High Preist's Maid isn't, I would say no unless only female servants aren't allowed to be Saducees.
-
High Preist's Maid isn't, I would say no unless only female servants aren't allowed to be Saducees.
She isn't currently, but I could definitely see where both could be identified as such, especially if Temple Guard is classified as one.
-
Neither of them are Sadducees. I've tried to get them both classified that way in the past and failed to convince TPTB. ;)
-
Malchus was among the other officers of the Chief Priests, I can't see how he's not considered a sadducee like the Temple Guard.
Not sure about Chief Priest's Maid.
-
i would give it to the pros and it could go either way...
-
I think either Temple Guard and Malchus should both be Sadducees, or neither should be.
-
Neither of them are Sadducees. I've tried to get them both classified that way in the past and failed to convince TPTB. ;)
But have you tried since you became a PTB? ;)
-
Malchus was a servant of a Sadduccee, not a Sadduccee.
Temple Guard is a guard and was never named a Sadduccee. I don't know why he was classified as one. Because he is printed on the card as a Sadduccee, that will have to be a mystery never to be solved. In short, it will have to stick.
Mike
-
Malchus was a servant of a Sadduccee, not a Sadduccee.
Temple Guard is a guard and was never named a Sadduccee. I don't know why he was classified as one. Because he is printed on the card as a Sadduccee, that will have to be a mystery never to be solved. In short, it will have to stick.
Mike
I agree that TG should remain classified as a Sadducee, but I also think that Redemption should work its standards around that. I hate "exceptions to the rule".
-
Hey,
We do have precedent of a card having an identifier on the card and the identifier being errataed off (King Ahaz). Although if you say Temple Guard isn't a sadduccee then the G deck has a crimson enhancement that can only be used by one black evil character and a black enhancement that can only be used by one character in the deck.
Tschow,
Tim "Sir Nobody" Maly
-
Hey,
We do have precedent of a card having an identifier on the card and the identifier being errataed off (King Ahaz). Although if you say Temple Guard isn't a sadduccee then the G deck has a crimson enhancement that can only be used by one black evil character and a black enhancement that can only be used by one character in the deck.
Tschow,
Tim "Sir Nobody" Maly
So, for next year... New starter decks so we can fix this? ;D
-
a little random- G/H sealed decks with 3 disciple packs...how good would that be?
-
a little random- G/H sealed decks with 3 disciple packs...how good would that be?
Terrible if you got the G deck.
-
a little random- G/H sealed decks with 3 disciple packs...how good would that be?
Terrible if you got the G deck.
Really? You wouldn't be happy to add any of the awesome brown/gold stuff from Disciples to your defense? What about an Aaron that can band to your Moses? Or Eli's Sound Advice? That all seems pretty amazing to me! ;D
-
a little random- G/H sealed decks with 3 disciple packs...how good would that be?
Terrible if you got the H deck, and prepare to lose the game you're about to play and a few after.
Fixed.
-
a little random- G/H sealed decks with 3 disciple packs...how good would that be?
Terrible if you got the G deck.
Really? You wouldn't be happy to add any of the awesome brown/gold stuff from Disciples to your defense? What about an Aaron that can band to your Moses? Or Eli's Sound Advice? That all seems pretty amazing to me! ;D
The G deck has NT Crimson/Black on defense, and an OT Green/Gold offense. The H deck has a NT Purple/White offense (featuring 2 disciples already), and an OT Gold/Brown defense.
Main cards good of G deck offense: Aaron, Behold the Lamb, John the Baptist, Kindness
Main cards good for G deck defense: Disbelieving Sadducees, Philetus, Peter's Curse (I guess), Questioning Christ's Authority, Scribe, Tennants Kill the Son, Herod's Temple
Main cards good for H deck: ... almost everything else.
The odds are weighted heavily in H's favor.
-
Even if there are more useful cards to G deck, H deck is better by itself...
An Aaron moses band would be almost impossible to deal with in sealed.
-
well then lets not do it...