Cactus Game Design Message Boards
Redemption® Collectible Trading Card Game HQ => Official Rules & Errata => Ruling Questions => Topic started by: adotson85 on December 07, 2010, 07:07:42 PM
-
sites can be added to battle at any time.. correct?
Also, I need someone to confirm that color on sites do not count as good brigades in play.
-
Sites can be added at anytime. But if it's a stalemate, it would transfer inish.
Sites are neutral, so they shouldn't count.
-
ur kidding
hopefully not in resolution
-
Sites can be added at anytime, by the attacker
Just a note, don't get too clever!
-
During battle anytime you can play a dom I believe.
They don't count, boy.
-
During battle anytime you can play a dom I believe.
They don't count, boy.
In resolution?
-
You cannot play dominants in resolution.
-
Sites can be added to battle from play to gain access at any time during battle. Sites are neutral, so although they have a brigade it is not good or evil.
-
Sites can be added to battle from play to gain access at any time during battle. Sites are neutral, so although they have a brigade it is not good or evil.
Thank you.
-
Sites can be added to battle from play to gain access at any time during battle. Sites are neutral, so although they have a brigade it is not good or evil.
then heros can not rescue from sites
-
Sites can be added to battle from play to gain access at any time during battle. Sites are neutral, so although they have a brigade it is not good or evil.
when did this come into play?
-
It's always been that way
-
It's always been that way
then a large amountr of players have and will play this wrong.
-
Sites can be added to battle from play to gain access at any time during battle. Sites are neutral, so although they have a brigade it is not good or evil.
Rulebook (http://www.redemptionreg.com/REG/battlephase.htm) " Matching Brigade "
if the site is not a good Brigade then it does not Match
-
If you are site locked and you attacked and your opponent choses not to defend then you add a site, could you still be in battle or is it too late to add a site? I am geussing it is too late but we play the other way. I would like to know the correct way so I won't have to defend.
-
Given the Harvest Time discussion, I'd say they get another chance to choose to defend.
-
Kittens are correct.
-
yup they get to choose whether they want to defend the battle challenge then they get to choose whether they want to choose the rescue attempt.
-
The brigade can match without the alignment matching. However, there is an inconsistency here. If "matching brigade" can refer to a Neutral Blue card (Hormah) and a Good Blue card (Jacob), why don't the Brigades match when it's Evil Gold and Good Gold? Why can I Discard Kozarin from hand to save my Gold Hero, but I can't Discard it to save my Gold Evil Character, and I can't Discard a Gold GE to save a Gold EC or a EE to save a GC?
-
The brigade can match without the alignment matching. However, there is an inconsistency here. If "matching brigade" can refer to a Neutral Blue card (Hormah) and a Good Blue card (Jacob), why don't the Brigades match when it's Evil Gold and Good Gold? Why can I Discard Kozarin from hand to save my Gold Hero, but I can't Discard it to save my Gold Evil Character, and I can't Discard a Gold GE to save a Gold EC or a EE to save a GC?
Evil Gold and Good Gold are two different brigades. They only share the same hue, which is perceived by your eyes as Gold. (or yellow, depending on your experience in Redemption). Gamewise, they're as different as Orange and Teal.
-
That actually isn't true, Kittens. Wariors Battle Prayer has been ruled to retrieve either gold; there is precedent for what Pol is saying.
-
Warriors battle prayer shouldnt retrieve evil enhancement and I think Kittens makes a good point why...
Will sites be considered good cards in the future?...
-
That actually isn't true, Kittens. Wariors Battle Prayer has been ruled to retrieve either gold; there is precedent for what Pol is saying.
Type: Hero Enh. • Brigade: Yellow • Ability: 3 / 3 • Class: None • Special Ability: Search through your draw pile or discard pile and select one gold enhancement card. Shuffle card pile. • Play As: Search your deck or discard pile for any good or evil gold brigade enhancement and place it in hand. • Identifiers: OT, Depicts a Weapon, Involves Music • Verse: Psalms 140:7-8 • Availability: Warriors booster packs (Common)
Because of that ruling, the REG specifies that it can recur a good [gold] or evil gold brigade enhancement, meaning they are different brigades.
SomeKittens is correct.
-
Play as are wording clarifications. They are there to make the ability more clear to newer players. I don't see how adding good or evil to the ability would agree with him necessarily. Clearly they are different brigades. I don't think either Pol or I ever argued they were the same.
-
i would say adding "good" or "evil" to the card would be best