Cactus Game Design Message Boards
Redemption® Collectible Trading Card Game HQ => Official Rules & Errata => Ruling Questions => Topic started by: Gohanick on August 15, 2010, 11:56:32 PM
-
Situation:
Opponent has Job in territory.
I have stalks of flax active.
May I use stalks to exchange for job? (It's not harm and I do as much as I can on stalks correct?)
Situation + 1:
I also have a dust and ashes in my set-aside and my opponent has a dust and ashes in his set aside. I rescue with my stolen job and my opponent harms job. Where does job go?
-
The owner of Job and Dust & Ashes can choose to "instead" Stalks of Flax, because it is harm. Harm is "any effect from cards not of the same alignment (i.e., good, evil, or neutral) targeting a character", and Stalks of Flax is a different alignment than Job.
-
interesting...
if that is true... then that begs this question
what happens if job is exhcanged with a converted laban?
Laban (P)
Type: Evil Char. • Brigade: Gray/Pale Green • Ability: 2 / 7 • Class: None • Special Ability: You may exchange your female Genesis Hero with opponent's male, human Hero for 7 turns. Limit twice per game. • Identifiers: OT Male Human, Magician (Syria-Aramea) • Verse: Genesis
-
I'm not sure Laban's ability works when converted, because it would harm a Hero before conversion.
-
Besides, who's the n00b playing without Magic Charms active ;)
Or House of Rimmon down :)
-
Tim Im suggesting you convert laban then make a RA and then exchanging for job. Exchanging for heroes should still work as a converted ability (Judah exchanges) and it is the same affinity as job
-
I know a converted Complainers can exchange heroes as well.
-
Couldn't any special ability now convert (except Play evil/Band to evil) with the current rule? Nothing a converted EC does can technically harm a hero, since harm can only come from other alignments... Once the EC is a hero, they're a good alignment, and can thus no longer harm another hero...
-kinda confused-
-
The owner of Job and Dust & Ashes can choose to "instead" Stalks of Flax, because it is harm. Harm is "any effect from cards not of the same alignment (i.e., good, evil, or neutral) targeting a character", and Stalks of Flax is a different alignment than Job.
Lolwut?
Since when is exchanging two heroes in territory harm?
And I'd really like to know who thought that definition up
-
anyways... where does an exchanged job go if there are 2 dust and ashes out and he is harmed
-
anyways... where does an exchanged job go if there are 2 dust and ashes out and he is harmed
If there does happen to be an exchanged Job and two D&A out, then Job would actually go to neither place. D&A says "If your Job is harmed or defeated...". Since your = own + control, then your Job applies to neither player, since one owns it and the other controls it. So if Job is discarded during that battle, he goes to the owner's discard pile.
-
alright didn't recheck that wording. Nice to know that something can be done : ) just need to remove him from discard pile