Cactus Game Design Message Boards

So I've posted a few things about this deck (including the PoC1 version that I played at the Type 2 Only), but this was the final list that I brought to Nats. Comments on card choices at the end of each block.

101 Cards

29 Neutral
Lost Souls: 14
Wicked x2
Covet x2
Exiles x2
Hunter x2
Prosperity x2
Distressed x2
Remnant
Darkness
A fairly standard OT package, by my understanding. I considered going for more souls that focus on ongoing abilites over the instant ones that will be negated by Call if I draw them in my d4 every time I attack, but for the most part I think that the abilities on these are far too important to skip. Running two Exiles with two Hunters was very good at finding Signet Ring on turn 1. When building the deck I didn't have access to a second Remnant, and convinced myself that a one-of Darkness was better because a turn 1 King TP is so strong. I think it activated once all tournament.

Three Woes
Destruction of Nehushtan
Self-explanatory. Two very powerful dominants.

Majestic Heavens
Treacherous Land
MH is one of the only soul generators this deck has, but was initially put in the phase 1 version of the deck before Storehouse was a thing. Now that there's other access for almost if not everything in reserve, it's not really needed, but topdecking something during prep can guarantee that Isaiah draws it for immediate use. TL is just good, especially with Endless Treasures.

Hidden Treasures
The Great White Throne x2
Ram’s Horn
Endless Treasures
Great White Throne is vital to the deck - grabbing angels makes you draw more, grabbing minor prophets slows your opponent, and the second ability that everyone forgets is 90% of why the deck works. Hidden Treasures is a no-brainer in a prophets deck, especially since His Name lets you get rid of any ECs they try to hide in their hand. Endless Treasures is great with three curses and an idol in reserve. I managed to play it three times in a single turn thanks to some Delivered shenanigans. Ram's Horn is a bit situational, and maybe shouldn't be here. It combines with Michael below to make a CBI Protection of Jerusalem, which is very very nice but generally not needed or worth setting up.

Razor x2
Delivered
God’s Mercy/Jonah’s Anger
Fifth Bowl of Wrath
Second Seal/War
If I could run more Delivereds I absolutely would. Razor and Delivered are both Isaiah cards, so Isaiah grabs them back from discard. Never say no to extra battlewinners/tutors. There used to be two Mercy/Anger, but I cut it for space. Whether it's good or evil is really matchup dependant - I don't have a way to recur it, so it can be a tough choice. It got used far more often evil (since once PoJ is set up they don't really get to play good enhancements), but it often finds better value if its good since it can stop Mourn and Weep, Wages of Sin, Death of Unrighteous, etc. Since you usually drop PoJ as soon as you find it, Anger can also get rid of the one you have once you have the full combo to make it CBI. Fifth Bowl was added mostly because I was having trouble with Red Dragon and KoT's CBP protection - same reason why Two Bears is still in the deck. War is great for pulling Horses.

36 Good
Son of God
The Second Coming
Angel of the Lord
Guardian of Your Souls
Grapes of Wrath
If you're running T2 without Guardian, what are you doing? Grapes is mostly defensive, and if I use it that way I get to dc my Assyrian to boot.

Heavenly Temple
Storehouse
Noah’s Ark (Ark of Salvation)
City of Refuge
I'm convinced people are sleeping on City of Refuge. Especially here - the fortress and Angel of His Presence combined made my heroes (especially Jonah) very safe even before Ark came out. I initially had a Whirlwind in reserve (since Hidden Treasures and a 0/1 Isaiah make it playable) but ended up swapping to Ark for hero protection, since it's in set aside and can hold I am Holy. Storehouse is just a great card. Heavenly Temple initially went in as a joke, but with how much this deck loves Great White Throne having a chance to activate other artifacts in addition to GWT is actually pretty solid.

You Will Remain
Only one, because Nahum does the same thing. This may actually be cuttable - I'm pretty sure it ended up mostly being Woes/art removal bait.

The basic idea of the deck is that it uses Protection of Jerusalem's "When you discard an evil Assyrian, negate and discard an evil card" with the "at any time, you may discard an evil card in territory" on Great White Throne and the (usually CBN) "When an evil character is in battle, you may discard your Assyrian" on Nahum. When Isaiah gets going and you're drawing ten cards a turn, you're more than happy to trade evil characters 1 to 1, especially when you have Jonah strongly discouraging search (with the shuffle two!) and Habakkuk discouraging drawing.

The deck plays in two main phases. It’s very, very powerful once it gets rolling, but that usually takes 3-5 turns. You’re looking for five things to set up: Wheel Within a Wheel, Four Living Creatures, Isaiah’s Call, Protection of Jerusalem, and either Great White Throne or Nahum. Wheel and 4LC grabs you two OT angels the turn you get them together, and one more each turn after, meaning that you can get your full five very quickly for maximum Isaiah draws. If your first hero you pull with Wheel or Throne is Seraph With a Live Coal, you can use it to grab a Call to get Isaiah out right away. Even during setup phase, this deck rarely attacks with anyone other than Isaiah or SwLC.
Once you have both PoJ and Great White Throne, how many evil cards your opponent has in play is entirely dependant on how many Assyrians you’re willing to discard. If Isaiah’s speed is up and rolling, you usually have much more cannon fodder than they have cards. Nahum is a little slower than GWT, since he only works when there’s an EC in battle, but since you can always pay a cost without getting the benefit you can snipe as many cards as you want without actually adding him to battle, and he has the bonus of being CBN (a DoN can actually negate the discards on GWT and undo everything if PoJ isn’t CBI from Ram’s Horn).

The Ram’s Horn combo is often superfluous, but can be lifesaving. If an opponent blocks and you immediately PoJ to get rid of the blocker, they do still have special initiative against PoJ. It has to specifically be able to negate a card outside of battle (interrupt the battle doesn’t work), but it is possible, and you don’t even get the evil character back for you troubles. Making PoJ CBI is incredibly powerful, although Ram’s Horn will often discard itself the turn you use it (unless you can Delivered something else active), so it can still be vulnerable to removal and then you’re back with a standard one.

One thing that can help a lot, especially during the setup phase when you’re not immediately destroying every evil character your opponent plays, is Potter and the Clay in reserve. Grabbing this with Emmaus Road or Storehouse will let you decrease Isaiah, and as it turns out a 0/1 hero with CBN enhancements is pretty good. The best part is, if they ever try to decrease him further to get rid of him, you can just heal him back up to 7/ 8 with Angel of His Presence!

Game Summaries:
Game 1: Luke Anderson
Similar archetypes, but he didn't have many newer cards. He couldn't find a hero and most of his evil characters died quickly, leading to my 7-0 win.
Game 2: Noah Wagnecht
We both got off to a good start, but since my TC characters are so important the side-battle Song of Moses meant that I finished setting up long before he did and began picking apart his offense with Jonah. That combined with the fact that PoJ counters carebear led to a 7-3 win.
Game 3: Jay Chambers
This was the first game broadcasted. Jay got off to a much faster start - Moses hurts my setup a lot, and by midgame I was behind 5-2. I misplayed hard several times - getting in at 1 am the night before combined with the excitement and stress of playing at the top table, on camera. That said, he was also running an Assyrian defense, so when I got Protection of Jerusalem his defense left the table and never really came back. I managed to deck out and come back to win from behind, 7-6.
Game 4: Josiah Beers
I didn't find any angels until turn five, and no PoJ until seven. Without my speed, I couldn't draw enough defense to hold off Josiah's offense. By the time I finally got rolling, it was too late - he had six and it was all I could do to drop my big two before he found his SoG. I lost 3-7, though we agreed that if we were playing to ten I likely could have pulled it off.
Game 5: Brandon Frank
This was a slow game - neither of us really got going. I got enough of my combo to frustrate him, but didn't actually find PoJ until the very last turn. I won 5-3 on the timeout.

Excellent deck and analysis...really intrigued to see if you keep finding ways to improve this deck in the upcoming season or if you start working on a new deck. 

I haven't decided yet.... it might decide on what new toys I have to play with next set 

None. This is such a silly deck. We decided not to print any Green or Pale Green cards next year

Quote from: Red Dragon Thorn on August 05, 2019, 04:41:47 PM

Quote from: Bobbert on August 05, 2019, 02:53:04 PM

I haven't decided yet.... it might decide on what new toys I have to play with next set 

None. This is such a silly deck. We decided not to print any Green or Pale Green cards next year

So I'm getting another Isaiah angel and more silver tutors? Sounds great!

And about 50 more Assyrian's to choose from... 

Haha, nice! I'm glad someone played this in t2. I played this in t12p at Iowa States, and it's a ton of fun! KTP3 is BRUTAL, love pulling that out on an unprepared opponent. Definitely makes it worth playing unity assyrians. Did you ever try out this deck with Mighty Warrior?

All I'm saying is, I've won games blocking with no other character than TP3.

The original version of the deck (back in PoC1) actually had 2x Mighty Warrior. That said, I think the only time he ever actually entered battle was in my game with Justin at the T2 Only, where I decided to try droughting him. There's just no reason to attack with anyone other than Isaiah 90% of the time, so I fit in more tutors and punish.